All studies
CompletedNot ApplicableInterventional

SOLVE: A trial randomising patients between a medical device (called Dilapan-S) and the standard pessary drug (Propess) to compare them in the process of cervical ripening before induction of labour

When a pregnancy needs to be started artificially (induced), the neck of the womb (cervix) must first soften and open. In the UK, this is usually done using a hormone pessary called Propess. While Propess works well, it can sometimes cause contractions to happen too quickly, which may cause stress for the baby. The SOLVE trial is testing a drug-free alternative called Dilapan-S. Dilapan-S uses small, sterile rods placed into the cervix. These rods slowly absorb natural fluid, gently swelling to open the cervix without any medication. Researchers want to see if Dilapan-S works as well as Propess while causing fewer side effects. Women taking part are randomly chosen to receive either Propess or Dilapan-S. Midwives monitor mother and baby closely throughout, and participants fill in a brief survey about their experience after birth.

At a glance

Status
Completed
Phase
Not Applicable
Sponsor
Birmingham Women’s and Children’s NHS Foundation Trust
Enrolment target
860
Start
30 Jun 2017
Estimated completion
27 Jan 2021

What is this study about?

Induction of labour is a common procedure in NHS hospitals. It is offered when it is safer for a baby to be born than to remain inside the womb. Before active labour can begin, the cervix (the entrance to the womb) must soften, thin out, and start opening up. This initial stage is known as 'cervical ripening'.

Currently, the standard UK treatment is a small vaginal pessary containing a hormone called dinoprostone (brand name Propess). The pessary slowly releases the hormone into the vagina to start the ripening process. While it is very effective, the hormones can sometimes make the womb contract too strongly or too often. If this happens, it can reduce oxygen flow and distress the baby.

Dilapan-S offers a non-hormonal approach. It consists of thin, smooth rods made from an absorbent material that contain no active drugs. When inserted into the cervix, they gently take up fluid from surrounding tissues, expand, and naturally stretch the cervix open. Because no medication enters the bloodstream, it does not trigger sudden, strong contractions.

The SOLVE study aims to find out whether this mechanical device provides a better or gentler experience for mothers compared with standard drug treatment, while ensuring both mother and baby remain safe and well cared for.

Key takeaways

  • The SOLVE trial compares a standard hormone pessary (Propess) with a drug-free expanding rod (Dilapan-S) for inducing labour.
  • Dilapan-S prepares the cervix mechanically without hormones, which reduces the chance of overly strong contractions.
  • Participants are assigned to one of the two treatments at random by a computer.
  • Care is delivered during your normal hospital stay, with no extra appointments or follow-up visits needed.
  • Taking part is entirely voluntary and does not change your right to standard NHS maternity support.

Who may be eligible?

This study is for pregnant women aged 16 and older who need their labour induced at 37 weeks of pregnancy or later. To be eligible, you must be expecting a single baby whose head is pointing downwards (ready for a head-first birth), and your waters must not have broken yet.

You cannot take part if you have already started having regular, painful labour contractions, or if your waters have already broken. The study is also not suitable for women who are already receiving medicines to speed up labour (such as oxytocin), those who have had more than one past caesarean birth, or anyone with certain severe pregnancy complications such as eclampsia.

Could this study suit you?

Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.

  1. I am at least 16 years old.
  2. I am at least 37 weeks pregnant with one baby.
  3. My baby is head-down, ready for a vaginal birth.
  4. My waters have not broken yet.
  5. My doctor or midwife has recommended that my labour be induced.
  6. I have not had more than one previous caesarean section.
Answer every question to see your result.

What does participation involve?

If you decide to join the study, you will first sign a consent form. A computer will then randomly allocate you to receive either the standard Propess hormone pessary or the Dilapan-S rods. You have an equal chance of receiving either method.

A doctor or midwife will insert the chosen treatment into your vagina or cervix. Your healthcare team will look after you and monitor your baby's heartbeat just as they normally would during an induction. You will be asked to complete a short questionnaire sharing your thoughts on how comfortable and satisfied you felt during the process. There are no extra hospital visits or blood tests required; once your baby is born and you are discharged, your participation is complete.

Potential risks and benefits

Taking part may not give you any personal medical advantage over standard care, but your feedback will help doctors improve induction care for other women in the future. Both treatments carry some risks. Propess can cause contractions that are too strong in about 1 in 20 women. Dilapan-S can cause mild pelvic discomfort or cramping during placement. There is an extremely low risk of infection (around 1 in 100,000) or difficulty removing the rod (around 5 in 100,000). You are free to leave the study at any point, and choosing to stop will never affect the quality of NHS care you or your baby receive.

Locations (3)

  • City Hospital Birmingham
    Approximate
    Birmingham, England
  • Heartlands Hospital
    Approximate
    Birmingham, England
  • Birmingham Women's and Children's Hospital
    City only
    Birmingham, England

Common questions

Will joining this study delay my induction?

No. Both Propess and Dilapan-S are active treatments used to start the induction process right away.

Can I choose which treatment I receive?

No. A computer system picks the treatment at random, like flipping a coin, so researchers can make a completely fair comparison.

Does inserting Dilapan-S hurt?

Having Dilapan-S placed feels similar to having a routine cervical screening (smear test) or an internal examination. Some women feel mild discomfort or light period-like cramps.

Can the Dilapan-S rods harm my baby?

The rods do not contain any drugs or hormones, so no chemicals reach the baby. They sit in the cervix and do not touch the baby directly.

What happens if I change my mind after joining?

You can withdraw from the study at any time without giving a reason. Your midwife and doctor will continue to support you with standard NHS induction care.

How to find out more

Amanda Cotterill

Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.

Discussion

Community discussion

Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.