Intensive Weight Loss Intervention Versus Usual Care for Adults With Obesity
This study looks at two ways to help adults with obesity. One is an intensive weight loss (IWL) programme. This programme includes a special diet of meal replacements, help and support to change habits, and weight loss medicines if needed. The other way is 'usual care,' which means the weight management services already available through your GP. The researchers want to find out if the intense programme is more helpful, safe, and cost-effective than standard care. They are interested in people with a certain level of obesity who don't have other complex health problems related to their weight.
At a glance
What is this study about?
This research study is called LightCARE. It aims to understand the best ways to help adults who are living with obesity. The study wants to compare a new, intensive weight loss programme with the typical care that people currently receive for their weight in the UK. This is important because obesity can affect many aspects of a person's health and quality of life, and finding effective ways to manage it is a key health goal.
The intensive weight loss programme is quite structured and lasts for two years. It's broken down into different stages. In the beginning, it involves a total change in diet using meal replacements, along with support to help you change your eating habits. If you're not losing enough weight, medication might be added. Later on, you'll gradually reintroduce healthy foods, start physical activity, and continue with support and medication if needed. The final stage focuses on keeping the weight off through healthy eating and active living, with medication as required. If some weight is regained, you might go back to an earlier stage.
On the other hand, 'usual care' means the regular weight management services available through your local doctor (GP) or local council. These services can vary a bit depending on where you live in the UK, but they generally offer advice on diet, nutrition, and healthy behaviours. By comparing these two approaches, the study hopes to find out which one offers the most benefits, is safest, and provides the best value for money in helping people manage their weight.
Key takeaways
- This study compares an intensive weight loss programme with standard care.
- The intensive programme includes special diets, support, and optional medication.
- The study lasts for two years and aims to help adults with obesity.
- It's for people aged 18-60 with a certain BMI and no complex health conditions.
- Researchers want to know which approach is most effective and cost-efficient.
- Participation is by invitation only.
Who may be eligible?
To take part in this study, you would first need to be invited. Generally, you need to be an adult between 18 and 60 years old. You also need to have a certain Body Mass Index (BMI), which is a measure that combines your height and weight. For most people, this means a BMI of 30 or higher. If you have a South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African, or African-Caribbean background, a BMI of 27.5 or higher might be considered.
There are certain reasons why someone might not be able to join the study. For example, if you have very complex obesity with serious health problems like heart disease or type 2 diabetes related to your weight. You also can't join if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or planning to become pregnant in the next two years. If you've recently used certain weight loss medicines, had weight loss surgery (except for very specific types that have been removed a long time ago), or have certain other medical conditions like untreated cancer or some eating disorders, you would also likely not be able to participate. Conditions that make a total diet replacement difficult or risky, or complicate certain weight loss medications, would also prevent participation.
Finally, if another person in your household is already in this study, or if you are currently involved in another study that deals with obesity treatment, you would not be eligible. The researchers want to make sure the study is safe and that results are clear.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- Are you between 18 and 60 years old?
- Do you have a BMI of 30 or higher (or 27.5+ if from certain ethnic backgrounds)?
- Are you NOT pregnant, breastfeeding, or planning to get pregnant soon?
- Do you NOT have severe obesity with other serious health problems like heart disease or type 2 diabetes?
- Have you NOT had certain weight loss surgeries or used specific weight loss medications recently?
- Are you NOT currently being treated for serious cancer or an eating disorder?
What does participation involve?
If you are invited and decide to take part in this study, you would first give your informed consent, which means you understand what's involved and agree to participate. The study would last for two years.
If you are in the intensive weight loss group, you'd follow a specific plan. This includes a period of total meal replacement for about 12 weeks, along with support for changing your habits. Then, over about 20 weeks, you'd slowly reintroduce healthy foods, start light exercise, and continue with support. Weight loss medication might be introduced at any stage if needed. The rest of the two years would be focused on maintaining your healthy habits.
If you are in the usual care group, you would receive information about standard weight management options available through your GP or local council. Both groups would likely have regular check-ups with the study team to monitor your health and progress, though the exact number of visits isn't detailed here. These visits would involve assessments to see how you are doing.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (10)
- The Department of Medicine and the Gastro Unit, Copenhagen University Hospital - Amager and HvidovreVerified postcodeCopenhagen, Denmark
- Frederiksberg kommune: Social-, Sundheds- og ArbejdsmarkedsområdetVerified postcodeFrederiksberg, Denmark
- The Parker Institute, Copenhagen University Hospital - Bispebjerg and FrederiksbergVerified postcodeFrederiksberg, Denmark
- Hvidovre kommune: Center for Sundhed og Ældre, Hvidovre Sundhedscenter, Sundhed og ForebyggelseVerified postcodeHvidovre, Denmark
- Gladsaxe kommune: Social- og Sundhedsforvaltningen, Sundhed og RehabiliteringVerified postcodeSøborg, Denmark
- West Midlands RRDNVerified postcodeBirmingham, United Kingdom
- South West Peninsula RDN, ExeterVerified postcodeExeter, United Kingdom
- Yorkshire and Humber RRDN (Leeds, Sheffield and Hull)Verified postcodeLeeds, United Kingdom
- North West RRDNVerified postcodeManchester, United Kingdom
- East of England RRDNVerified postcodeNorwich, United Kingdom
Common questions
What is 'usual care' in this study?
'Usual care' means the regular weight management services that are already available through your local doctor or council in your area.
Will I need to take medication in this study?
In the intensive weight loss group, weight loss medication might be offered if needed to help with weight loss, but it's not automatically given to everyone.
How long does the study last?
If you join the study, your participation in either the intensive programme or usual care will be for two years.
What does 'total dietary replacement' mean?
It means for a period, your usual meals would be replaced with specially formulated shakes or soups to manage your calorie intake very carefully.
Can I join if I'm planning to get pregnant?
No, if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or planning to become pregnant in the next two years, you would not be able to join this study.
How to find out more
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.